DIY Nutella

(That Won’t Make Your Kids Bounce Off the Walls)

As Seen on WFMZ-TV69 on Saturday Sunrise 

Let’s be honest — store-bought Nutella is delicious, but have you seen that sugar content? One spoonful and suddenly your toddler thinks they’re starring in Fast & Furious: Living Room Drift. Enter this dreamy, creamy, dietitian-approved version from YMCA nutritional wizard Shawn Borup. It’s sweetened with dates (nature’s candy), made with hazelnuts (hello healthy fats), and totally customizable with cocoa or carob powder. Spoiler: you’ll be eating it straight off the spoon after bedtime. No judgment.

Homemade Nutella fruit dip with apples on a wooden tray, Healthy chocolate hazelnut spread next to sliced apples, YMCA nutritious homemade Nutella with dates and hazelnuts

Ingredients:

  • ¾–1 cup hazelnuts

  • 1 cup filtered water

  • 2 cups Medjool dates

  • ¼ cup carob powder or cocoa powder

  • 1 tsp vanilla extract

Shawn suggests going organic with your ingredients when you can — especially those dates and hazelnuts — because better ingredients = better spread (and less mystery in your pantry).

Truth Bombs About the Sweet Stuff (aka why Homemade Nutella is the hero we need):

  • Heads up: Cacao powder is strong stuff. Use a little less than you would with cocoa or carob.

  • Nutella says it’s a “hazelnut spread with cocoa.” Sugar is the first ingredient and not the picture of health. It’s 55% sugar. 

  • Oh and P.S.? Sugar + refined palm oil = a not-so-dreamy duo with known carcinogenic properties. Big yikes.

  • Eating sugar lights up your brain like a Christmas tree. It activates natural opioids — basically, your brain throws a party and forgets to send the eviction notice. Some studies say it can be addictive. (No wonder you can’t stop at one spoonful.)

  • And just for fun: Sugar also messes with your mood, your metabolism, and your waistline. It’s the frenemy of food — sweet on the surface, chaos underneath.

  • Dates to the rescue! Unlike refined sugar, dates bring fiber to the party — helping you feel full and slowing down the sugar spike. They’re nature’s way of saying, “I got you.”

Directions:

  1. Soak dates in warm water for 30 minutes.

  2. While that’s happening, blend the hazelnuts and filtered water in a blender to soften them up.

  3. Drain and pit the dates, then toss ’em in the blender.

  4. Blend for about a minute, or until it looks like creamy dessert magic.

  5. Transfer to a bowl, stir in the vanilla and carob/cocoa powder, and try not to eat it all in one sitting.

How to Use It:

  • As a fruit dip (make apples exciting again!)

  • Swirled into yogurt or oatmeal

  • In smoothie bowls

  • Or straight-up on a slice of whole-grain toast

Share:

Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
LinkedIn

Related Posts

YMCA of Reading & Berks County swim team at YMCA Nationals 2025

Making Waves on the National Stage

After a phenomenal season full of grit, early mornings, and unforgettable moments, our Reading Y swimmers made a national splash. With top-tier individual finishes, relay records, and that unbeatable Y spirit, these athletes brought their A-game and came home as certified national competitors.

Homemade Nutella fruit dip with apples on a wooden tray, Healthy chocolate hazelnut spread next to sliced apples, YMCA nutritious homemade Nutella with dates and hazelnuts

DIY Nutella

Made with real ingredients (and zero sugar rushes), this chocolatey dream spread is perfect for lunchboxes, snack attacks, and 2 a.m. cravings.